The Fourth Wife by Linda Hamilton Review: When Gothic Horror Meets Sister Wives
“What did it matter to a man if he wrought horrors to create the vision he saw? He would still be called righteous for it.” – The Fourth Wife by Linda Hamilton
I used to watch Sister Wives the way it’s intended: as a slow-moving, train wreak of a social experiment. I couldn’t look away from it. There’s a line from the shows intro (spoken by the husband) that’s straight out of a nightmare and has lived rent-free in my brain ever since:
“Love should be multiplied, not divided.”
I don’t know if I’ve ever fully recovered from that. Considering my mom and I still quote this at any given chance we get, I’d say the damage is forgoing. It will forever haunt me.
So when I saw The Fourth Wife by Linda Hamilton described as The Hacienda meets Sister Wives, I was completely sold. Gothic horror + polygamy + a haunted house? That is exactly the kind of unsettling type of story I cannot and will not ever resist.
This post could contain affiliate links, which means I would receive a small commission at no cost to you should you shop using the links.
The Fourth Wife by Linda Hamilton Summary
Set in 1880s Utah, The Fourth Wife by Linda Hamilton follows Hazel, a very young woman who enters into a polygamous marriage with Jacob Manwaring, becoming his fourth wife. While expecting a more traditional separation between households, Hazel instead arrives at his decaying mansion where all of his wives and children live together under one roof.
Hazel is immediately pulled into a tightly controlled world shaped by rigid religious expectations and silent yet expected rules. While the wives are bound together by circumstance, their relationships are strained by jealousy, grief, resentment, and something that feels just slightly off.
As Hazel settles into her new life, she begins to feel unsettling disturbances within the home: strange sounds and an increasing sense that something (or someone) within the mansion is watching her.
The Fourth Wife by Linda Hamilton Review
From the very beginning, I was so immersed. Linda Hamilton’s writing makes the setting feel so rich, making Hazel’s world so easy to sink into. The atmosphere is easily one of the strongest parts of this book. It feels layered and deeply rooted, and there’s this constant sense that something is slightly off, even in the quiet moments. And Jacob sure does LOVE his quiet house.
What makes this idea so appealing is that the horror is already embedded into the structure of the life Hazel is entering. A single home, multiple wives, a man at the center of everything, and an unspoken expectation that this is all normal, sacred, actually. <insert internal screaming here>
As an audiobook, the narrator does a great job at distinguishing the tension between the wives, which is subtle but constant. Each woman seems to be responding differently to the same reality they’re forced to share, which gives the household this fractured, uneasy energy.
At some point, though, I realized I was waiting for something to shift. Not necessarily some crazy dramatic twist, but a true sense of escalation. A moment where the tension transforms into something more defined and unforgettable.
I felt myself suddenly become unattached to a story that had me locked for more than 75% of the time. I think for me, the story stays in this space of ongoing dread, which, over time, became more of this muted feeling rather than a haunting atmosphere.
The Fourth Wife by Linda Hamilton Final Thoughts
At its core, The Fourth Wife is more about what it means to live inside a structure where intimacy and control blur into something really unsettling.
The premise is definitely compelling and the writing is beautifully immersive. Plus, the idea of Sister Wives inside a gothic horror framework is genuinely chef’s kiss levels of unhinged in a way that absolutely spoke to me. I’m not entirely sure what all that says about me…
Overall, this is more of a haunting idea of a story than a properly delivered one.
And don’t forget, underneath all of it, there’s that echo from Sister Wives I couldn’t shake while reading.
“Love should be multiplied, not divided.” It’s truly something right out of a horror movie.
shop this post
